Compression project.
 Compression project (most info is in Russian) >> About
In English: Video >> Public filters | Com. filters | Video Codecs Comparisons |
Our Video Codecs | Video Quality Metrics     ||     New: Compression Catalog!
  Personal (English) >> V.Yoockin | A.Ratushnyak
In Russian: "Compression Methods" book | Arctest | Download | FIDO | Forum | Links
---------------------------------------------------------
Hot news:
* 5-th H.264 comparison!
* Video Quality Metric 2.01 released!
* Cartoon Restore now x5-10 faster!
* New Subtitle Remover 2.0!
If you find a spelling error, please select an incorrect text and press Ctrl+Enter. Thank you!
Compression project >> Video Area Home  
RUSSIAN VERSION HERE!

Second Annual MSU MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 Video Codec Comparison


For people, who make real research in field of high-end video compression and professionally use videocodecs

MSU Graphics & Media Lab (Video Group)

See NEW VERSION on Fourth Annual H.264/AVC comparison page!

See also Frequently Asked Questions. Second annual MPEG4-AVC/H.264 codecs comparison

Project head: Dr. Dmitriy Vatolin
Testing, charts, analysis: Dmitriy Kulikov, Alexander Parshin
Translation: Artem Titarenko
Verification: Stanislav Soldatov

 

Codecs that were tested

  • DivX 6.0 (Not H.264 video codec, tested as reference codec)
  • ArcSoft H.264
  • Ateme H.264
  • ATI H.264
  • Elecard H.264
  • Fraunhofer IIS H.264
  • VSS H.264
  • x264

    •  

    Comparison content

  • During testing following metrics were measured:
  • PSNR (Y, U, V, L, R, G, B components)
  • SSIM (Y component)
  • VQM (Y component)
  • Blurring (Y, U, V components)
  • Blocking (Y, U, V components)

  • Two codec presets will be compared:
  • “Maximum quality”
  • “Balanced” (speed)

  • Video sequences that were used in this comparison
  • “foreman” (standard sequence)
  • “susi” (standard sequence)
  • “BBC” (standard sequence)
  • “battle” (part from "Terminator-2" movie)
  • “simpsons” (part from "The Simpsons" movie)
  • “Matrix” (part from "The Matrix" movie)
  • “Concert” (part from HDTV movie)

  • Testing rules:
  • Restrictions of codecs’ operation: only codecs that can work in Main profile of H.264 and do not use two passes were tested.
  • Every codec was tested three times with separate speed measurements. After this median of these three values (middle value) was used as a resulting time.
  • Following 10 bitrates were used for codec testing (Kbps): 100, 225, 340, 460, 700, 938, 1140, 1340, 1840, 2340.
  • During testing three types of video sequences were used:
  • Source sequences *.yuv in YUV 4:2:0 format.
  • *.avi sequences in YUV 4:2:0 format with fourcc “YV12”.
  • *.yuv sequences with duplicated last frame. These sequences were used for testing x264 codec.
  • In this testing VirtualDub version 1.6.10 was used.
  • In this testing AviSynth version 2.55 was used.
  • For all metrics’ measurements in this test special build of MSU Video Quality Measurement Tool was used.
  • For each preset both speed and quality were measured

    •  

    Comparison statistic

  • Total number of graphs in this comparison is 3796. Only 82 (2%) of them are in document;
  • The number of computer-days is more than 20;
  • Final document has 85 pages.

    •  

    Content of HTML version

  • Introduction
  • Thanks
  • Overview
  • Goal and testing rules
  • Sequences
  • Codecs
  • "Best quality" preset
  • Y-PSNR
  • U-PSNR, V-PSNR
  • SSIM, VQM
  • Blurring measure, blocking measure
  • Bitrate handling
  • Time
  • "Best speed" preset
  • Y-PSNR
  • Speed/Quality Tradeoff
  • Bitrate handling
  • Time
  • Final part
  • 2-pass mode and High profile
  • Per frame comparison
  • Visual comparison
  • Informal codec comparison
  • General conclusions

    •  

    Download

  • Second Annual MSU H.264 Video Codec Comparison - PDF (3560 Kb)
  • Second Annual MSU H.264 Video Codec Comparison - ZIP (2636 Kb)

    • If you are interested in your codecs' testing or tuning, please write to us at

     

    Contact Information

    or

    See all MSU Video Codec Comparisons

    MSU video codecs comparisons resources:

     

    Other materials

    Video resources:

    Public MSU video filters
    Here are available VirtualDub and AviSynth filters. For a given type of digital video filtration we typically develop a family of different algorithms and implementations. Generally there are also versions optimized for PC and hardware implementations (ASIC/FPGA/DSP). These optimized versions can be licensed to companies. Please contact us for details via video(at)graphics.cs.msu_ru.     		MSU filters for companies
    We are working with Intel, Samsung, RealNetworks and other companies on adapting our filters other video processing algorithms for specific video streams, applications and hardware like TV-sets, graphics cards, etc. Some of such projects are non-exclusive. Also we have internal researches. Please let us know via video(at)graphics.cs.msu_ru if you are interested in acquiring a license for such filters or making a custom R&D project on video processing, compression, computer vision.
    Codecs comparisons
    Objective and subjective quality evaluation
    tests for video and image codecs
    Ext. link: x264 parameters efficiency comparison
    		MSU Video Quality Measurement tools
    Programs with different objective and subjective video quality metrics implementation
    Video codecs projects
    Different research and development
    projects on video codecs     		Other
    Other information

    Bookmark this page:   Add to Del.icio.us Add to Del.icio.us     Digg It Digg It     reddit reddit

     
    Last updated: 26-March-2009
    Search (Russian):
    Server size: 7898 files, 968Mb (Server statistics)

    Project updated by
    Server Team and MSU Video Group

    Project sponsored by YUVsoft Corp.

    Project supported by MSU Graphics & Media Lab
     
    ---------------------------------------------------------
      Send your comments to compression_##_graphicon.ru
      © Dr. D.Vatolin, Dr. M.Smirnov, A.Ratushnyak, V.Yoockin, content, 2001-2008
       © A.Andreev, pictures, 2002

    Rambler's Top100 Ðåéòèíã@Mail.ru Ñèñòåìà Orphus

    This document available from http://www.compression.ru/video/codec_comparison/mpeg-4_avc_h264_2005_en.html