Compressors Comparison Test, issue 6.6, November 2003.

Telephone base dictionary file (627,761 bytes)


Environment:

iPIII-840, 256Mb SDRAM, XPsp1,
IBM Deskstar 80Gb.

@ Dictionary (ca.fdb) (627,761 bytes) (from foliant)
RemarkArchiver and used optionsAlgorithmPacked sizePacked ratioPacking time (sec.)Unpacking time (sec.)Rating (sec.)
*compressia 1.00 mf+PPMII609650.9036.195.8328.95
*compressia 1.00f+BWT+Ari628540.9000.810.3718.64
 paq4CM783120.87523.5023.6668.91
*ctx 0.75b1 mqf+PPMII806290.8720.580.2923.27
 ctx 0.75b1f+PPMII830280.8680.680.4024.14
 ctx 0.75b1 mef+PPMII848540.8650.810.5024.88
 sbc 0.969 b3m3f+BWT+Ari867770.8620.730.5225.35
 rkc 1.02 -o8f+PPMZ870670.86111.7810.5046.47
 rkc 1.02f+PPMZ873380.86112.1110.8847.25
 slim 18f+PPM*889250.85819.0417.4861.22
 rkc 1.02 -o6 -mxf+PPM927660.8525.604.7536.12
 rkc 1.02 -mxf+PPM934090.8516.055.2637.26
 epm r9f+PPMII935130.8516.265.9938.23
 uharc 0.5' mxf+PPM961260.8473.372.9232.99
 sbc 0.969 b3m1f+BWT+Ari1024020.8370.740.3029.49
 rkc 1.02 -mff+ROLZ1059580.8314.860.3234.61
*ace32 2.0c3 m5 d2048LZ+Huf1149780.8171.010.6733.62
 ace32 2.0c3 m4LZ+Huf1151620.8170.860.6533.50
*7zip 3.11 7z LZMALZMA1170470.8141.410.1834.10
*dc 0.99.298 -b512 fzf+BWT+Ari1180380.8120.380.2833.45
 dc 0.99.298 -mb -fl fzf+BWT+Ari1193950.81013.430.3246.92
 ppmonstr Ir1 o16 m64PPMII1203590.8085.896.4445.76
 durilca 0.3PPMII1203670.8085.625.6044.66
 epm r9 (0)PPMII1204220.80813.2113.1059.76
 dc 0.99.015f+BWT+Ari1209460.8070.410.2934.30
 ppmonstr Ir1PPMII1210880.8075.836.3945.86
 eri 5.10freST+PPM1217300.8060.920.4935.22
*rar 3.20b2 m5LZH/PPMII1219220.8060.710.0834.66
 rar 3.20b2 m4LZH/PPMII1224140.8050.610.0834.69
 rar 3.20b2 m3LZH/PPMII1233110.8040.540.0734.86
 paq3n/ic8CM1420880.77414.2614.2968.02
 rolz' 1.02ROLZ1440160.7711.820.3442.16
 rkc 1.02 -mf -a-ROLZ1441990.7702.390.3542.80
 rkc 1.02 -a-PPMZ1469250.76620.5520.7882.14
 uharc 0.5' mm-f+LZ+Ari1525270.7571.640.4544.46
 enc 0.15 b m64PPMII1561100.75131.6343.27118.26
 enc 0.15 b o6m64PPMII1678000.73326.0941.16113.86
 paq3cCM1685510.73212.2912.3771.48
*cabarc 1.00 LZX:18LZ+Huf1781390.7161.300.0550.83
 enc 0.15 m64PPMII1785090.71624.5139.20113.30
 cabarc 1.00 LZX:15LZ+Huf1799070.7130.710.0650.74
 xprs L6LZ+Huf1972450.6860.260.0755.12
 7zip 3.11 zip mxLZ+Huf1987090.6831.150.1256.47
 dst 0.9 mbLZ+DHuf1987450.6831.180.6157.00
 7zip 3.11 zipLZ+Huf1997060.6820.610.1256.20
 lz (Kabanov) 2LZ+Huf2104020.6650.430.1859.06
 bee 0.77 m3d5CM2108560.6643.423.5565.54
 bee 0.77 m2d5CM2108980.6643.423.4765.47
 lz (Kabanov) 3LZ+Huf2109600.6640.500.1859.28
 lzds 2.1 s64 m3LZ+Ari2109920.6640.480.1359.22
 arjz 0.50 mp5LZ+Huf2123300.6620.530.0959.60
 imp 1.10 -1 u1000LZ+Huf2124220.6620.370.0959.47
 arjz 0.50LZ+Huf2134000.6601.320.0960.69
 uc 2.3.05 tnLZ+Huf2148340.6580.460.0860.22
 uc 2.3.05 ttLZ+Huf2149000.6580.590.0860.36
 uharc 0.5' mzf+LZP2162880.6550.590.7161.38
 ppmn 1.00b1++ O9 RL3PPM2201750.6493.233.3967.78
 dzip 2.90LZ+Huf2216730.6470.400.0762.05
 ppmn 1.00b1++ O9PPM2219190.6463.273.4568.36
 pkzip 2.50 maxLZ+Huf2229220.6450.290.0862.29
*pkzip 2.50LZ+Huf2229970.6450.230.0762.24
 jar32 1.02d m3LZ+Huf2236770.6441.290.1763.59
 durilca/lt 0.3 t1(9)f+PPMII2236970.6441.860.8464.84
 ha 0.999c a1LZ+Ari2255310.6412.220.3265.19
 ppmn 1.00b1++PPM2264640.6392.642.8068.35
 arhangel 1.40a1 -1LZ+Ari2267020.6391.070.1964.23
 arc' (I.Sutton) m1BWT+Ari2271430.6380.310.3163.72
 GRZipII 0.2.1 m3 -aBWT+Ari2275580.6380.680.6964.58
 uhbc 1.0 m3BWT+Ari2292250.6352.071.7367.47
 uhbc 1.0BWT+Ari2296480.6341.581.2966.66
 uhbc 1.0 m1BWT+Ari2299630.6341.040.7665.68
 uhbc 1.0 m0BWT+Ari2315180.6310.830.6165.75
 esp 1.92LZ+Huf2336340.6280.240.0465.18
 ctw/es 0.1 n16M d8CTW2339480.62712.9213.4391.34
 ctw 0.1 n16M d8CTW2339480.62714.7314.9794.69
 ctw/es 0.1 n16MCTW2345680.62612.1712.6589.98
 ctw 0.1 n16MCTW2345680.62613.7614.0893.00
 GRZipII 0.2.1 m3BWT+Ari2349610.6260.690.7366.69
 gca 0.90kBWT+Ari2367480.6230.720.4066.88
 ash02CM2391340.61910.4411.1087.97
 ybs 0.03f -rm256kBWT+Ari2397350.6180.570.3767.53
 GRZipII 0.2.1 -aBWT+Ari2428520.6130.840.5868.88
 GRZipII 0.2.1 m4BWT+Ari2443490.6110.520.4768.86
 ppmy 2.02 9a9CM2452990.60915.9416.67100.75
 ybs 0.03f -rBWT+Ari2472670.6060.600.4369.72
 bwtcoder2/ybsBWT+Ari2477570.6050.980.8070.60
 bwtcoder2/dcBWT+Ari2477830.6050.880.8770.58
 durilca/lt 0.3PPMII2478810.6051.111.2271.19
 ppmd I o16 m64PPMII2479350.6051.071.1971.13
 ICT UC 1.0ST+Ari2493300.6030.770.5070.53
 szip 1.12 b21 o6ST+Ari2493510.6030.540.3870.18
 szip 1.12 b21 o0BWT+Ari2493730.6030.900.2970.46
 szip 1.12 b21 o4ST+Ari2493900.6030.230.3669.87
 ba 1.01b5 -24-r-zBWT+Ari2494020.6030.850.5870.71
 bsicBWT+Ari2495230.6032.272.2273.80
 ybs 0.03f -m256kBWT+Ari2508970.6000.560.4070.65
 GRZipII 0.2.1BWT+Ari2513490.6000.830.6071.25
 7zip 3.11 7z PPMDPPMII2523580.5981.341.4072.84
 sbc 0.969f+BWT+Ari2526050.5980.850.4571.47
 ba 1.01b5BWT+Ari2526320.5980.840.5871.60
 zzip 0.35g -mxBWT+Ari2531630.5970.780.6371.73
 abc 2.4BWT+Ari2549670.5941.341.3073.46
 GRZipII 0.2.1 m2BWT+Ari2583080.5890.670.4072.82
 xprs FBWT+Ari2589460.5880.500.2372.66
 ppmd IPPMII2592070.5870.921.0373.95
 bwc/PGCC 0.99 m900kBWT+Ari2599590.5860.700.3773.28
 ybs 0.03fBWT+Ari2604670.5850.610.4573.41
 qlfc 6.6wBWT+Ari2606840.5850.610.3973.41
 dc 0.99.298 -aBWT+Ari2619260.5830.520.3973.67
 ann p12PPM+NN2621060.5824.154.1581.11
 arc' (I.Sutton)BWT+Ari2626700.5820.640.4874.08
 ha 0.999c a2PPM2632590.5815.425.0483.59
 boa 0.58b m7PPM2636380.5806.736.6686.62
 bzip2/PGCC 1.0b7 -6BWT+Huf2659140.5760.580.2574.70
 abc 2.4 -1BWT+Ari2711030.5680.590.5576.45
 bzip2/PGCC 1.0b7 -9BWT+Huf2746590.5620.580.2577.12
 exp1 1.BWT+Huf2747290.5620.630.2377.17
 imp 1.10 -2 u1000BWT+Huf2750160.5620.410.1876.98
 hap 3.00PPM2772860.5581.721.9480.68


Best compressor is near right bottom corner. Drag mouse to change time balance on Y axis


Marks:
* there are no another compressor, that compress better with faster compression and decompression speed.
' non public compressor.
Rating is calculated as a time required to compress file, transmit
it using 28000 bps connection and decompess file back.
Most of compressors are available at
ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack
Vadim Yoockin ( yoockinv@mtu-net.ru ).